| CP.1 | Creative Thinking: questioning, exploring, brainstorming, working or discussing activities. | Has problems identifying ideas and concepts for a work of art. | Brainstorms information for a work of art from own knowledge, class instruction and outside sources around the subject. | Makes selection and elaborates upon an idea for a work of art after the analysis of multiple ideas and options. | Hypothesizes adaptations from the initial ideas for a work of art. | Demonstrates originality and innovation. |
| CP.4 | Planning: Making decisions about how resources and time will be used. | Works with little or no plan for how to produce an artwork. | Creates an artwork with basic revisions based upon internal and external critique. | Exhibits maturity of thinking in reception of critique. Is able to admit mistakes or difficulties and devises new strategies to solve problems. | Analyzes the feedback from peers, the effects or impact of work as well as own perspective and desires. Demonstrates flexibility in expansion or editing work because of assessment. | Completes work after multiple revisions and is able to share working process with others in a way that is inspirational. |
| CP.5 | Skill and Craftsmanship | Handles materials in a limited way and lacks an understanding of the techniques, methods and conventions used to create work. | Uses materials in a basic way to create work. | Demonstrates dexterity and skill in creating a work of art. | Able to adapt materials to create their own distinctive mark, style or identifiable characteristic. | Craftsmanship and construction of work (form) is fully integrated with the ideas (content) and is aesthetically excellent. |
| CP.6 | Observation: Experiencing works of art. | Description of visual data is inaccurate and is unaware of an artist's methods and creative intent. | Recognizes an increasing number of formal elements in works of art and attempts to interpret them using a wider range of perceptual methods. | Identifies significant qualities of an artwork and employs a wide range of sensorial and aesthetic methods to explore their own intuitive and aesthetic responses. | Compares and contrasts the aesthetic qualities of an artwork or visual data to infer meaning in a sophisticated manner. Is able to express own experience of visual data or a work of art creatively. | Conveys a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of an artwork. Able to hypothesize about the artist’s intent and to ask relevant questions for further research or inquiry. |