Points of View

When President Kennedy was shot that fall, I heard the news over the radio while I was alone painting in my studio…. I’d been thrilled having Kennedy as president; he was handsome, young, smart—but it didn’t bother me that much that he was dead. What bothered me was the way the television and radio were programming everybody to feel so sad…. It seemed like no matter how hard you tried, you couldn’t get away from the thing.

Andy Warhol, POPism: The Warhol Sixties, 1980

Well, Kennedy was sort of this savior, this prince, and they called his administration Camelot. And when he died it seemed that he took the dreams—I was 13—the dreams of the future generations were shattered when he was killed…. I’ve never looked at government and politics in quite the same way after that. I no longer think that our elected officials are competent.

Interview with New York woman,
Roy Rosenzweig and David Thelen, The Presence of the Past: Popular Uses of History in American Life, 1998

Her face is as familiar to me as that of my mother. As a small child I even associated Jacqueline Kennedy with Mom: poised and elegant, with the same thick dark hair, tailored suits, pillbox hats and white gloves. But here, Jackie seems less a maternal object than a religious icon. The thirty-two jewel-colored squares look like a wall of stained glass. Do the images reveal the gracious First Lady or the stunned widow? The photos seem to tell both stories. Do the multiple images enable us to empathize with Jackie, or do they destroy her uniqueness by making her a commodity? If she has become a brand-name product, like Warhol’s Campbell’s Soup Cans and Marilyns, can we ever recover the “real” Jackie? And what are we, as insatiable consumers of gossip about her and the Kennedy family?

Paula Kane, Point of View Labeling Project, The Andy Warhol Museum, 2001

Warhol rendered Jackie—celebrity/victim—in his standard grid, repeating images as if they were mug shots, frames of documentary film footage, or a fan’s clippings. Repetition implies mourning: the Dallas scene is a trauma, and mourning takes the form of recycling and recall, a process that unsettles chronology…. Repetition implies commodification: Jackie no longer has control over her own image…. Repetition implies obsession: the Jackie photos are cropped—narrowing the focus onto Jackie alone, myopically isolating her from context…. A narrative emerges, and it is not the story of Jackie’s life or the growth of Jackie’s soul—but the narrative of the image and of our relation to the image.

Wayne Koestenbaum, Jackie Under My Skin: Interpreting an Icon, 1995

Discussion Questions

1. Look at the images. Who is this woman? If you do not know who this is, try to guess. For example, is there any evidence that she is famous?
2. Warhol cropped this image from larger pictures of events. Speculate what is happening in the background.
3. Describe this woman’s emotions. What clues do the paintings give to make you think this?

Procedure

1. Introduce flashbulb memory and collective memory.
2. Students write about a flashbulb memory of an event or an important moment that had an impact on their lives.
3. Students pair with someone and share their responses.
4. Students discuss the following questions: What are some events that have affected everyone’s life? What experience have you lived through that you wouldn’t want other people to forget? What are your personal memories of that moment? Make a group list of the events. Pick one that seems to have the broadest impact.
5. Students define collective memory as a group using the written responses to support their definition.
6. Collect reproductions from the internet and media representing the news event chosen from Step 4. Students work in small groups to crop, copy, enlarge, or reduce the pictures in preparation for a repetitive collage. Using Warhol’s Jackies as a guide, collage and repeat the images using different color variations and compositions. Mount the finished project on a large piece of paper or mat board. Each group should prepare a short artist statement.

Wrap-up

In a class critique, students read their artist statements and discuss their finished projects, their decision-making processes, and the effect repetition has in each work.

Possible discussion questions:

1. Does repetition strengthen or weaken the emotional value of the work?
2. In what ways does your artwork reflect collective memory?

Extension

1. Present this quote by Susan Sontag:
   “In the real world, something is happening and no one knows what is going to happen. In the image-world, it has happened, and it will forever happen in that way.“
2. Students discuss or write a reflective essay on the quote and Sontag’s use of the term “image-world.”
3. Listen to the collection of recorded memories. 
4. Have students compare and contrast these memories with those they collected during the assignment.